In this blog, two Castalia staff comment on the evidence base for the New Zealand “Three Waters” reforms. Andreas Heuser, who has lived mostly in New Zealand, and Lewis Whitelaw who has lived mostly in Scotland, describe how the government’s advice and analysis has included inappropriate comparisons between New Zealand and Scotland and why this is important in the context of New Zealand water sector reform. Although New Zealand and Scotland share unspoiled natural landscapes and picturesque lakes (or lochs for Scottish readers) their urban geography and urban water networks are quite different.
The New Zealand government is proposing a major reform of drinking, waste, and storm water services (Three Waters). The Government appointed the Water Industry Commission for Scotland (WICS) to provide analysis that has underpinned the reform proposals. WICS isthe economic regulator of Scottish Water, the publicly-owned monopoly water service provider in Scotland. WICS has drawn key conclusions for the New Zealand reform proposal from Scotland’s geography and water service experience. Conclusions like: “Scotland and New Zealand share many common geographical features – it seems likely, therefore, that the level of expenditure (before consideration of the potential for efficiency in asset management and capital expenditure delivery) required to achieve particular outcomes should be broadly similar …”. The government relies on WICS modelling for two claims:
- That significant capital investment is needed in the New Zealand water sector,
- The amalgamation of the water services of the 67 local authorities into four separate entities is the only way to achieve the cost-efficiencies to make the reform affordable.
The image below shows the Government’s proposed four entities and predicted household bills based on WICS’ modelling.
Figure 1: Government’s proposed four entities and predicted household bills based on WICS’ modelling
Castalia has advised local authorities on the reform proposal
Castalia has advised several local authorities located in all of the four entity zones on whether the reform scenario will deliver the claimed benefits. We provided each with a robust understanding of the underlying assumptions that underpin the claimed benefits and uncovered key risks associated with the reform proposal. This included a detailed analysis of the geographic comparisons between Scotland and New Zealand made in the WICS modelling.
WICS justifies using Scotland as a model on the grounds that New Zealand has a low level of population density. WICS also assumes that the amalgamated New Zealand entities will achieve a 50 per cent capex efficiency improvement based on the single observation of claimed capex efficiencies in Scotland between 2002-2021. WICS suggest amalgamation will drive economies of scale efficiencies by “asset optimisation” (that is, the ability to consolidate water networks between towns).
Is New Zealand really like Scotland?
New Zealand and Scotland have comparable populations, 4.8 million and 5.3 million respectively. But the similarities start to end there.
New Zealand has a land area slightly larger than the whole of the United Kingdom, and therefore a much smaller population density. New Zealand is also highly urbanized. The population mostly lives in urban towns with significant distances between them. Of the total New Zealand population, 87 percent live in urban environments. New Zealand’s urban population increased by 8 percent between 1996 and 2018.
In Scotland, 83 percent of the population lives in urban environments. The urban population of Scotland is declining, according to the Scottish census agency.
The image below shows the population densities and significant distances between towns in the proposed Entity C. The residents live across a wide geographic area, in a mixture of mostly urban settings. More than 500km by air separates Tairāwhiti and the East Cape from Takaka and Golden Bay (including the Cook Strait).
Figure 2: 3D population density map: Reform proposal Entity C
The towns and cities in Entity D are also separated by large distances, as the next image shows.
Figure 3: 3D population density map: Reform proposal Entity D
In comparison, most of the Scottish population live in towns and cities that are relatively close to one another. Around 80 percent of the Scottish population live in the central belt area that includes three of the four major Scottish cities Glasgow, Edinburgh, and Dundee as shown in the image below.
Figure 4: 3D population density map: Scotland central belt
The differences between Scotland and New Zealand lead to implausible findings in the water reform modelling
WICS claims similarities between parts of New Zealand and Scotland based on levels of urbanisation. However in the modelling, population density is used. As these images demonstrate, the population density is very different.
In water services, geography is important for the cost and quality of service. Denser urban areas tend to have lower average costs of service. Water services with more dispersed customers must distribute drinking water, and pump wastewater over longer distances with more pipes, dispersed treatment infrastructure, and higher costs.
If New Zealand is to achieve the cost savings that WICS says have occurred in Scotland, then these key differences in the geography must be acknowledged. The distances between New Zealand towns mean that any benefit of physical joining of networks will not be justified due to the cost of transporting water (pipes and pumps). Water is valuable, but unlike oil and electricity, its value-to-weight ratio is low. To get economies of scale in water networks, network mergers only make sense where communities are close enough so that the transport costs of moving water, chemicals, and water engineering and technical staff from one place to the other are low.
Unfortunately, WICS’ modelling assumes that cost savings are largely driven by the number of people served by a single entity, ignoring the question of how far the residents are from each other. This is inconsistent with the economic literature or the reality of running a water utility. The WICS efficiency claims cannot be reconciled with the urban geography of New Zealand. In some cases where water networks are close together and the administration is merged, efficiency gains are possible. However, such instances have already been mostly exploited in New Zealand, like in Wellington and Lower Hutt which have shared a water network for over 100 years, and have been under shared management since 2014 or Nelson City and Tasman District which share a wastewater treatment plant. The administrative amalgamations of disconnected and distant water networks in the New Zealand reform proposal are unlikely to produce the significant efficiency gains claimed in WICS’ modelling.
About the authors
Andreas Heuser is a Director at Castalia and New Zealander. He has led the Castalia analysis on New Zealand’s water sector reform. Andreas has stressed the importance of geographical considerations on the claimed benefits of the reform proposal.
Lewis Whitelaw is an Analyst at Castalia, Scotsman, and a New Zealand resident. He has contributed to Castalia’s water sector advice since his arrival from Scotland. Having lived in both Scotland and New Zealand, he was surprised to see the geographical comparisons made by WICS.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Veryy rapidly this web site will be famoous among all blog users, due to it’s pleasant articles. https://livetvgoo.com/
It’s nice to see the best quality content from such sites. https://freehorseracingtv.com/live/
Greetings! Very helpful advice in this particular article! It is the little changes which will make the most important changes. Thanks a lot for sharing! https://oneotv.uk/
Good article with great ideas! Thank you for this important article. Thank you very much for this wonderful information. live greyhound racing
You have noted very interesting details! ps decent web site. w hill racing
I have read so many content concerning the blogger lovers however this paragraph is genuinely a pleasant piece of writing keep it up.newsmax app for android
You have noted very interesting details! ps decent web site. https://yoykem.com.tr/
Thank you for great content. I look forward to the continuation. https://no19butik.com/
Wonderful post! We will be linking to this great article on our site. Keep up the great writing https://farmasiucretsizuyelik.com/
I really don’t know what you have written, it is very helpful for me because I keep coming here. I also want to help you if you want to go to USA and buy some outfits from here, then you must try this Harry Styles 2023 Grammy White Jacket.
I just like the helpful information you provide in your articles
First of all, your blog was amazing, besides, for those who follow the outfits of movie stars, this Tom Cruise Top Gun 2 Green Jacket is the best outfit, which is reasonable in terms of money and quality.
You’re so awesome! I don’t believe I have read a single thing like that before. So great to find someone with some original thoughts on this topic. Really.. thank you for starting this up. This website is something that is needed on the internet, someone with a little originality!
Nice post. I learn something totally new and challenging on websites
Good post! We will be linking to this particularly great post on our site. Keep up the great writing
Very well presented. Every quote was awesome and thanks for sharing the content. Keep sharing and keep motivating others.
Cool that really helps, thank you.
Awesome! Its genuinely remarkable post, I have got much clear idea regarding from this post.
Assignment UK provides excellent customer service. Their team of customer service representatives is available 24/7 to answer any questions or concerns that clients may have. They also provide a live chat feature on their website so that clients can get in touch with them quickly and easily. Furthermore, they offer a money-back guarantee someone write my assignment if clients are not satisfied with the quality of work they receive. This ensures that clients can get the help they need without having to worry about wasting their money.
Your blog is really cool and great. I really appreciate your blog. I am glad to read your blog. Thanks for sharing the nice and cool post. Battery Injury Lawyer Toronto Keep it up. I am waiting for your next blog.
Stunning site! Do you have any helpful clues for trying essayists? I’m wanting to begin my own site soon yet I’m somewhat lost on everything. Would you prompt beginning with a free stage like or go for a paid alternative? There are so many Wednesday 2022 Jenna Ortega Bomber Jacket alternatives out there that I’m totally overpowered .. Any thoughts? Welcome it!
I appreciate you sharing this blog post. Thanks Again. Cool.
Nice post. I learn something totally new and challenging on websites
Pretty! This has been a really wonderful post. Many thanks for providing these details.
I have read your article carefully and I agree with you very much. This has provided a great help for my thesis writing, and I will seriously improve it. However, I don’t know much about a certain place. Can you help me?
I like the efforts you have put in this, regards for all the great content.
Hi there to all, for the reason that I am genuinely keen of reading this website’s post to be updated on a regular basis. It carries pleasant stuff.
I think this post makes sense and really helps me, so far I’m still confused, after reading the posts on this website I understand.
Pretty! This has been a really wonderful post. Many thanks for providing these details.
I’m often to blogging and i really appreciate your content. The article has actually peaks my interest. I’m going to bookmark your web site and maintain checking for brand spanking new information.
You’re so awesome! I don’t believe I have read a single thing like that before. So great to find someone with some original thoughts on this topic. Really.. thank you for starting this up. This website is something that is needed on the internet, someone with a little originality!
I really like reading through a post that can make men and women think. Also, thank you for allowing me to comment!
I like the efforts you have put in this, regards for all the great content.
Nice post. I learn something totally new and challenging on websites
I just like the helpful information you provide in your articles
Awesome! Its genuinely remarkable post, I have got much clear idea regarding from this post
I just like the helpful information you provide in your articles
Awesome! Its genuinely remarkable post, I have got much clear idea regarding from this post.
I am truly thankful to the owner of this web site who has shared this fantastic piece of writing at at this place.
This is really interesting, You’re a very skilled blogger. I’ve joined your feed and look forward to seeking more of your magnificent post. Also, I’ve shared your site in my social networks!
You’re so awesome! I don’t believe I have read a single thing like that before. So great to find someone with some original thoughts on this topic. Really.. thank you for starting this up. This website is something that is needed on the internet, someone with a little originality!
For the reason that the admin of this site is working, no uncertainty very quickly it will be renowned, due to its quality contents.
This is really interesting, You’re a very skilled blogger. I’ve joined your feed and look forward to seeking more of your magnificent post. Also, I’ve shared your site in my social networks!
Pretty! This has been a really wonderful post. Many thanks for providing these details.
I’m often to blogging and i really appreciate your content. The article has actually peaks my interest. I’m going to bookmark your web site and maintain checking for brand spanking new information.
Very well presented. Every quote was awesome and thanks for sharing the content. Keep sharing and keep motivating others.
very informative articles or reviews at this time.
I appreciate you sharing this blog post. Thanks Again. Cool. at the races live stream
This is really interesting, You’re a very skilled blogger. I’ve joined your feed and look forward to seeking more of your magnificent post. Also, I’ve shared your site in my social networks!
Awesome! Its genuinely remarkable post, I have got much clear idea regarding from this post.